New Federal Sentencing Guidelines: Can You Get a Sentence Reduction?
In 2023, the U.S. Sentencing Commission made significant changes to the federal sentencing guidelines that can reduce the guideline ranges for certain federal defendants. These changes, known as Amendment 821, address how criminal history is calculated and provide a potential path to reduced sentences for some people who are already incarcerated.
Amendment 821 took effect on November 1, 2023. Certain portions of the amendment were also made retroactive, allowing eligible people previously sentenced to seek a reduction in their federal sentences.
If you or a loved one is serving a federal prison sentence, it is important to understand how Amendment 821 works and whether it could affect the sentence. The rules are specific, and not everyone will qualify for a reduction.
What Is Amendment 821?
Amendment 821 changed certain provisions of the federal sentencing guidelines related to criminal history. The amendment has two primary components:
- Part A: Changes how “status points” are calculated for certain defendants who committed their offense while under a criminal justice sentence.
- Part B: Creates a two-level offense-level reduction for certain defendants with zero criminal history points.
The changes can lower the federal sentencing guideline range for some defendants. However, eligibility depends on the specific circumstances of the case and the defendant’s criminal history.
How Did Amendment 821 Change Federal Sentencing Guidelines?
Before Amendment 821, defendants could receive two additional criminal history points if they committed their offense while serving a criminal justice sentence, such as probation, parole, supervised release, or imprisonment.
Amendment 821 changed how these status points are applied. Under the amended guidelines, defendants with six or fewer criminal history points generally no longer receive status points. Defendants with seven or more criminal history points may receive one status point instead of two.
This change can result in a lower criminal history score and, in some cases, a lower federal sentencing guideline range.
What Are Status Points?
Status points are additional criminal history points that may be assigned when a person commits an offense while under certain forms of criminal justice supervision, such as probation, parole, supervised release, or imprisonment.
Amendment 821 limited the impact of these points by eliminating them for defendants with six or fewer criminal history points and reducing them from two points to one for defendants who meet the new requirements. For some defendants, this change can make a significant difference in the applicable sentencing range.
What Is the Zero-Point Offender Reduction?
Amendment 821 also created a new guideline, Section 4C1.1, for certain zero-point offenders. A zero-point offender is someone who did not receive any criminal history points under Chapter Four, Part A of the federal sentencing guidelines. For eligible defendants, Section 4C1.1 provides a two-level reduction in the offense level.
This does not mean that every person with no prior criminal history automatically qualifies. The defendant must meet additional requirements.
Who Qualifies as a Zero-Point Offender?
To receive the two-level reduction under Section 4C1.1, a defendant must meet specific criteria. Among other requirements, the defendant must:
- Have received no criminal history points under Chapter Four, Part A.
- Not have received an adjustment for terrorism.
- Not have used violence or credible threats of violence in connection with the offense.
- Not have committed an offense that resulted in death or serious bodily injury.
- Not have been convicted of a qualifying sex offense.
- Not have personally caused substantial financial hardship.
- Not have possessed, received, purchased, transported, transferred, sold, or otherwise disposed of a firearm or other dangerous weapon in connection with the offense.
The complete eligibility requirements should be reviewed before assuming that a defendant qualifies for a sentence reduction.
Can Amendment 821 Reduce an Existing Federal Sentence?
Yes. Certain portions of Amendment 821 were made retroactive, meaning eligible people already serving federal sentences could seek reductions under the amended guidelines.
The Sentencing Commission authorized retroactive application of Part A and Part B, Subpart 1 of Amendment 821. Courts can consider eligible sentence-reduction requests under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(2).
The retroactive provisions became effective February 1, 2024. The Commission delayed the effective date of sentence reductions to give courts, the Bureau of Prisons, attorneys, and others time to review cases and prepare for the reentry of people whose sentences were reduced.
However, retroactive application does not guarantee that a person’s sentence will be reduced. The defendant must first qualify under the applicable amendment, and the court must decide whether a reduction is appropriate.
How Much Could a Federal Sentence Be Reduced?
The potential reduction depends on which part of Amendment 821 applies and how the amended guideline range affects the individual case. For zero-point offenders who qualify under Section 4C1.1, the amendment provides a two-level reduction in the offense level.
Part A can also lower the guideline range for defendants who previously received status points. The Sentencing Commission estimated that 11,495 incarcerated individuals could have a lower sentencing range under the status-point changes, with an average potential sentence reduction of 11.7%.
It is estimated that another 7,272 incarcerated individuals could qualify for a lower sentencing range as zero-point offenders, with an average potential reduction of 17.6%.
These figures are estimates, not guarantees. The effect of Amendment 821 on an individual sentence depends on the defendant’s guideline calculation and the specific facts of the case.
How Do You Apply for a Federal Sentence Reduction?
If you believe you or a loved one may qualify for a sentence reduction under Amendment 821, an attorney can review the original sentencing calculation and determine whether the amended guidelines apply.
A federal sentence reduction generally requires more than simply showing that a person meets one of the amendment’s criteria. The attorney may need to review:
- The original judgment and sentencing documents
- The Presentence Investigation Report
- The defendant’s criminal history calculation
- The original sentencing guideline range
- The offense conduct
- Whether status points were applied
- Whether the defendant qualifies as a zero-point offender
- Whether any of the amendment’s exclusionary criteria apply
- The defendant’s current sentence and time remaining
Because these cases involve federal sentencing rules, it is important to have an attorney who understands the federal sentencing guidelines and the requirements for seeking a sentence reduction.
Does Everyone Qualify for a Sentence Reduction Under Amendment 821?
No. Amendment 821 does not automatically reduce every federal sentence. Part A applies to certain defendants who previously received status points, while Part B, Subpart 1, applies only to zero-point offenders who meet additional requirements. The Sentencing Commission also explains that the eligibility rules differ between the two parts of the amendment.
Even when a defendant is eligible for consideration, the court must determine whether a reduction is appropriate under the applicable federal sentencing law. An attorney can review the sentencing record and determine whether seeking a reduction makes sense in a particular case.
Get Help With a Federal Sentence Reduction
If you or a loved one is serving a federal prison sentence, Amendment 821 may provide an opportunity to seek a reduced sentence. Determining whether the amendment applies requires a careful review of the defendant’s criminal history, the sentencing guideline calculation, the offense, and the current sentence.
The attorneys at Harrison & Hart, LLC can review your case and help you understand whether you may qualify for a federal sentence reduction under Amendment 821.
Call Harrison & Hart, LLC at (505) 295-3261 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.