Case Results

How to File a Civil Lawsuit in New Mexico

Filing a civil lawsuit in New Mexico can be a complex process. Whether you’re dealing with a contract dispute, personal injury claim, or property damage case, understanding the legal requirements is crucial.

While you can file a lawsuit on your own, working with an experienced civil litigation attorney can help ensure that your case is handled correctly, improving your chances of a successful outcome.

What Is a Civil Lawsuit?

A civil lawsuit is a legal dispute between two or more parties seeking monetary compensation or another legal remedy. Unlike criminal cases, civil cases are disputes between private individuals, businesses, or organizations.

Common Civil Lawsuits in New Mexico

Common types of civil lawsuits in New Mexico include:

• Contract disputes – When one party fails to uphold the terms of a contract.
• Personal injury claims – If someone’s negligence causes harm, such as in a car accident.
• Property damage claims – Seeking compensation for damage to personal or real property.
• Landlord-tenant disputes – Issues involving lease agreements, unpaid rent, or evictions.
• Debt collection – When someone owes money but has not paid.

However, New Mexico’s magistrate courts, which handle smaller civil claims, cannot consider cases involving divorce, custody, real estate title disputes, defamation, or misconduct by public officials. Additionally, magistrate courts can only hear cases where the amount in dispute does not exceed $10,000.

Step 1: Determine Jurisdiction and Venue

Before filing your lawsuit, you must determine the appropriate jurisdiction (the court’s authority to hear your case) and venue (the location where you file your claim).

In New Mexico, a civil lawsuit should be filed in the county where:

• The plaintiff (the person filing the lawsuit) lives.
• The defendant (the person being sued) lives.
• The incident that led to the lawsuit occurred.

If the defendant does not reside in New Mexico, the state’s courts may not have jurisdiction over them. An attorney can help determine the correct court for your case.

Step 2: Preparing and Filing Your Complaint

To start a lawsuit, the plaintiff must file a Civil Complaint with the appropriate court. This document must include the names and addresses of all parties involved, the plaintiff’s claim, and the amount of money being sought as compensation.

The Civil Complaint can be obtained from the New Mexico Courts website or at the Magistrate Court Clerk’s Office. The filing fee for a civil lawsuit in magistrate court is $77. If you’re requesting a jury trial, additional fees apply.

Step 3: Serving the Defendant

Once the complaint is filed, the defendant must be formally served with the lawsuit. Proper service ensures that the defendant is notified of the claim against them. New Mexico law requires that the plaintiff cannot personally serve the defendant. Instead, service must be completed by the county sheriff, a private process server, or any non-party adult (18 or older) who is not involved in the case.

How Can a Defendant Be Served?

Service can be done by:

1. Mail – Sending the complaint and summons via certified mail with return receipt requested.
2. Personal Service – Delivering the complaint directly to the defendant or an adult at their residence.
3. Posting – If personal service is unsuccessful, the documents may be posted at the defendant’s last known address and mailed to them.

After the defendant is served, a Return of Service form must be filed with the court. If this step is skipped, the case may be delayed or dismissed.

Step 4: The Defendant’s Response

Once served, the defendant has 20 days to file an Answer with the court. In their response, the defendant may admit or deny the claims, file a counterclaim against the plaintiff, or request the case be dismissed.

If the defendant fails to respond within the deadline, the plaintiff can request a default judgment, meaning the court may rule in favor of the plaintiff without a trial.

Step 5: Pre-Trial Procedures

Before the trial, both parties may engage in discovery, where they exchange evidence and witness lists. Additionally, either party can file motions, such as a request to dismiss the case or limit certain evidence.

A court may also encourage mediation or settlement negotiations to resolve the dispute without a trial. A skilled litigation attorney can negotiate on your behalf to reach a fair settlement.

Step 6: The Trial

If no settlement is reached, the case proceeds to trial. In magistrate court, a judge will hear the case unless a jury trial is requested. During the trial, both parties will present evidence, which can include witness testimony. Then, the judge or jury issues a verdict. If a party disagrees with the outcome, they may be able to file an appeal to a higher court.

Why You Should Hire a NM Civil Litigation Attorney

Filing a civil lawsuit in New Mexico can be overwhelming, especially if the case involves complicated legal issues or a large amount of money. Hiring our attorneys provides several advantages:

• Legal knowledge – An attorney ensures your case follows all legal procedures.
• Accurate filings – A lawyer can help you prepare and submit the correct documents.
• Stronger arguments – Attorneys know how to present a compelling case in court.
• Settlement negotiations – A lawyer can help you reach a fair resolution without going to trial.
• Trial representation – If your case goes to trial, an attorney will advocate for your best interests.

Contact a New Mexico Civil Litigation Attorney Today

If you’re considering filing a civil lawsuit in New Mexico, don’t go through the process alone. A knowledgeable litigation attorney can guide you through every step, from filing your complaint to negotiating a settlement or representing you in court.

Contact our firm today to schedule a consultation to discuss your case and explore your legal options.

How Does the New Mexico Court of Appeals Work?

The New Mexico Court of Appeals is critical to the state’s judicial system. It reviews decisions made by lower courts to ensure the law was applied correctly. The court handles both civil and criminal appeals, providing a crucial step for those seeking to challenge a trial court’s ruling.

Here’s what you need to know about the Court of Appeals, the appellate process, and the potential outcomes.

What Is the New Mexico Court of Appeals?

The New Mexico Court of Appeals is an intermediate appellate court that reviews decisions made by lower trial courts to ensure the correct application of law. It hears civil and criminal appeals, except for cases like death penalty matters.

How Is the NM Court of Appeals Structured?

The New Mexico Court of Appeals is comprised of 10 judges who sit in panels to review cases. These judges are divided between Santa Fe and Albuquerque.

The court is structured to handle appeals efficiently, with the panels rotating to ensure a fair distribution of the caseload. Cases are generally assigned randomly, and the panels consist of three judges each.

What Do Court of Appeals Judges Do?

Unlike trial courts, appellate judges do not re-examine witnesses or consider new evidence. Instead, they focus on whether legal errors were made in the original case. The judges review the written briefs, the trial court record, and any oral arguments presented. The panel will then issue a written opinion explaining their decision.

What Types of Cases Does the NM Court of Appeals Hear?

The court has jurisdiction over most civil and criminal appeals. Civil cases can range from family law disputes to business litigation, while criminal appeals often involve issues such as wrongful convictions or sentencing errors.

However, some cases—such as capital punishment appeals and cases involving public regulation— bypass the Court of Appeals and go straight to the New Mexico Supreme Court.

What Is the Appellate Process in the New Mexico Court of Appeals?

The appellate process begins with the filing of a notice of appeal. This document notifies the court and the opposing party that you intend to challenge the lower court’s decision.

Afterward, both parties submit briefs, written arguments explaining their position. The appellant argues why the decision should be overturned, while the appellee defends the original ruling. In some cases, oral arguments may be scheduled, allowing attorneys to present their case before the judges. However, many appeals are decided based solely on the written briefs.

How to File an Appeal in New Mexico

To file an appeal, there must be legal grounds to claim that an error occurred during the trial. These could include mistakes in applying the law, procedural errors, or insufficient evidence to support the trial court’s decision.

Appeals must be filed within a specific time frame, typically 30 days from the final judgment in the lower court. Missing this deadline can result in the loss of the right to appeal.

What Are the Possible Outcomes of an Appeal?

The New Mexico Court of Appeals has several options when deciding a case. The court can affirm the lower court’s ruling, meaning they agree with the original decision and the case is over.

Alternatively, they can reverse the decision, which may result in a new trial or the case being sent back to the lower court (remanded) for further proceedings. Sometimes, the court may modify the ruling without sending it back to the lower court, adjusting aspects like damages or sentencing.

What Types of Opinions Can Be Issued?

The court may issue one of three types of opinions:

• Published opinions establish precedent and can be cited as binding authority in future cases. They are carefully written and thoroughly reasoned, often addressing novel legal issues or clarifying existing law.
• Unpublished opinions resolve the case at hand but do not establish binding precedent. While these opinions are not published in official reporters, they are typically available online and can be persuasive in future cases.
• Memorandum opinions are brief decisions that dispose of the case without extensive legal analysis. They are used when the court believes a full opinion is unnecessary due to settled law or clear facts.

How Long Does the Appeals Process Take in New Mexico?

The process can take anywhere from six months to two years or more, depending on the complexity of the case and the court’s caseload.  Several factors can influence the timeline, such as delays in filing briefs, the need for oral arguments, and how quickly the panel reaches a decision.

Do You Need a Lawyer for an Appeal?

While you aren’t required to have a lawyer in an appeal, working with one can make all the difference in achieving a favorable outcome. Many appeals are lost due to technical mistakes or failure to meet deadlines. An attorney with extensive legal knowledge can craft persuasive briefs and present compelling oral arguments on your behalf to improve your chances of success.

Questions about an Appeal in New Mexico? Call Harrison & Hart, LLC Today

Whether you’re facing a civil or criminal appeal in New Mexico, understanding the court’s process can help you navigate this complex system.

If you’re considering an appeal in New Mexico, our experienced appellate attorneys at Harrison & Hart, LLC can help. We’ll guide you through each step of the process and fight for the best possible outcome in your case.

Call 505-295-3261 today or contact us to schedule an initial consultation.

What Constitutes Illegal Search and Seizure in New Mexico?

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects the privacy of all citizens. You have a right against unreasonable searches and seizures of your personal property from your person, home, business, and other places where you can reasonably expect privacy. There are legal safeguards to protect your privacy against illegal searches and seizures.

New Mexico Search and Seizure Laws

Both state and federal laws protect you against illegal searches and seizures. You cannot be searched, and your property cannot be taken unless law enforcement has probable cause to believe that a crime has been committed.

However, specific wording in the New Mexico state constitution makes the application of this 4^th Amendment right unique. This wording led to a definitive ruling in the case State v. Gomez.

Because of this case and others, “application of the New Mexico Constitution’s protections regarding search and seizure can lead to better outcomes for criminal defendants than the application of the Fourth Amendment protections enshrined in the U.S. Constitution.” In other words, the New Mexico Constitution offers you more protection than does the U.S. Constitution.

When Is a Warrant Needed?

In most situations, law enforcement must have a search warrant to search a person or their property and seize property.

If an officer has information that indicates you may be involved in a crime, they must seek a warrant from the court. Their request must have enough information to show probable cause that a crime was committed.

If officers want to search a specific person or location, they must have information showing that the person or place was involved in the crime. A police officer cannot just get a warrant based on a hunch.

Exceptions to When a Warrant is Needed

There are some exceptions to when a warrant is necessary, including:

• The circumstances are emergent
• The search will protect law enforcement or others from immediate harm
• Evidence is in plain view of an officer
• An officer is making an inventory of things collected during an arrest (all other regulations must be followed)
• The person voluntarily consented to a search

If any exceptions apply, a police officer or investigator may perform a search. If they find illegal objects, they can seize them under these circumstances.

When Is a Search and Seizure Illegal in New Mexico?

A search and seizure is illegal if an officer does not have probable cause that a crime has been committed. If they do not have a warrant to search you and there is no specifically mentioned circumstance as an exception, then any search and seizure may be illegal.

What Happens to Evidence Found Illegally?

Evidence recovered as the result of an illegal search and seizure may be excluded from the case. It would be considered inadmissible because it was obtained illegally.

Evidence obtained from an illegal search and seizure is called “fruit of the poisonous tree.” The Fruit of the Poisonous Tree doctrine excludes illegally obtained evidence.

Your criminal defense attorney can file a motion to exclude evidence obtained illegally. Without that evidence, the prosecutor may not have enough information to support your charges. If that is the case, then your charges may be dismissed.

It’s important to know that there are ways law enforcement can keep this evidence in a case. For example, if the prosecutor can prove it would have been discovered naturally regardless of the illegal search, it may be allowed to stay. You must work with a lawyer who can dispute these claims.

What to Do If You Believe You’ve Been Illegally Searched

It can be hard to challenge the validity of a search and seizure. You will need to have solid proof that your rights were violated.

You may be able to obtain evidence, including the officer’s body camera, eyewitness statements, and the police report. You will likely have to fight against the claims of the law enforcement officer.

If you think you were illegally searched, you should immediately contact a criminal defense attorney and tell them what happened. Write down exactly what happened and collect as much information as possible. Provide your lawyer with as many facts as possible.

Contact a New Mexico Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

If your constitutional rights have been violated, you have options regarding how to proceed. Your best step is to contact a criminal defense lawyer at Harrison & Hart, LLC. We will immediately start working on your case and ensure your rights are protected.

Call us today at (505) 295-3261 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.

Mass Tort vs. Class Action

You may be familiar with significant cases that involve hundreds or thousands of people against large companies that result in million-dollar settlements. These cases are often class action claims made by people with similar injuries.

However, another type of claim can involve a single defendant called a mass tort. Understanding the difference helps you know which type of lawsuit might benefit your claim.

What Is a Mass Tort Claim?

A mass tort claim is a group of lawsuits filed by many people individually. These lawsuits are generally related to personal injuries where people have been harmed due to defective or dangerous products. These claims hold large companies liable for injuries suffered by the public.

In a mass tort claim, plaintiffs can all use similar evidence against the defendants; however, they prove their damages separately. This reduces legal fees and discovery costs while maximizing compensation for each plaintiff.

When Would Someone File a Mass Tort Claim?

Mass tort litigation involves each plaintiff (person who was harmed) filing an individual lawsuit against the company because they have unique injuries.

Those injuries would be so different than those suffered by others that they deserve an independent consideration of compensation. In many cases, a person can obtain a greater amount of compensation when they conduct an individual lawsuit in a mass tort claim. Defective products, health code violations, and foodborne illnesses are some examples of mass tort claims.

What Is a Class Action Lawsuit?

A class action is another lawsuit involving multiple plaintiffs and one defendant. However, in these claims, the plaintiffs join in filing one lawsuit and seek a single settlement or jury verdict that will be split between the plaintiffs.

Class actions benefit plaintiffs because they put pressure on the defendant. Defendants facing class action lawsuits are often ready to settle the case and do away with the large claim.

Plaintiffs in class actions pool resources with the same law firm to pay for legal fees and costs and to obtain a larger settlement.

When Would a Class Action Lawsuit Apply?

A court must approve class action lawsuits. Multiple plaintiffs cannot file a class action without first having it approved.

A class action must involve many people with similar injuries and damages. Otherwise, the compensation obtained would not be fair to everyone involved. You might consider a class action suit in situations involving unsafe drugs, unfair business practices, or victims of fraud, among other cases.

A class action is beneficial when plaintiffs cannot afford legal counsel or do not wish to participate directly in a case. Additionally, if an injured person wants to file their claim, they may opt out of the class action in some circumstances. There are deadlines to opt out of a class action.

How Are Class Actions Different Than Mass Torts?

Some of the differences between class actions and mass torts include the following:

• Mass torts result in individual recoveries for each plaintiff, whereas class actions get one large settlement split among plaintiffs.
• One law firm represents everyone in a class action, while multiple firms may be involved in mass tort claims.
• A plaintiff may get a more significant recovery in a mass tort claim; however, they will also have more legal costs.

A Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help You Understand Your Options

If you have suffered harm similar to that of many other people, you could join a class action or file a mass tort claim. You have options to consider when approaching your case. You should consult a personal injury lawyer who can review your injuries and help you move forward.

Call Harrison & Hart, LLC at (505) 295-3261 or contact us online for a consultation.